Home / American Sports / Michael Phelps vs Usain Bolt: Who is the greatest Olympian of all time?

Michael Phelps vs Usain Bolt: Who is the greatest Olympian of all time?

Embed from Getty Images

The numbers game: Level of success

In claiming the historic “treble treble” Bolt achieved something that no other athlete has ever done before, and that is to defend all three sprint events successfully for three consecutive Olympics (Beijing, London and Rio). It also took his total medal haul to 9 Golds, the joint most of any male Athletics star, tied with Carl Lewis and Paavo Nurmi, giving him a 100% record in the last three Olympic games.

Whilst Bolt’s medal haul is far from shabby, it is Michael Phelps who takes this one, and by a country mile as well: 23 Gold medals, three silver and two Bronze medals for the ‘Baltimore Bullet’. Whilst merely looking at total number of medals would be insufficient, it is poignant that two other track athletes have done what Bolt has managed, yet no swimmer – male or female – has come remotely close to challenging Phelps’ record number of golds (the second most successful male swimmer is Ryan Lochte with 12 medals, 6 of them Golds).

That should prove enough to challenge those foolhardy people who claim Phelps’ medal haul is only so great because of the amount of opportunities he has to win – if what Phelps does is easy to accomplish, why has no other swimmer got into double digits for Olympic Gold Medals? And the answer is because no one can, and no one is willing to cram so many events into their schedule. Simple as that.

In regards to statistics, Phelps is the clear winner.

About Dan Culyer

I am a 17 year-old sport fanatic - particularly when it comes to football, formula one, tennis and swimming/ water polo! I am a part-time sports journalist, as well as a fully qualified football referee! I particularly enjoy doing in-depth opinion pieces, with detailed analysis of players, teams and tournaments!
@Dan_Culyer

Check Also

Alt="Joshua Kimmich celebrates his goal"

Joshua Kimmich: Football’s Next Big Thing?

  Bayern Munich have an appetite for developing fresh, young talent into world-class footballers and ...